From allegations of wrongful termination and discrimination to claims of harassment and retaliation, employment-related lawsuits can be financially devastating and damaging to a company’s reputation. Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) has become an essential risk management tool. However, simply purchasing a policy is not enough. To ensure robust protection, businesses must take a proactive, strategic approach. This checklist serves as a comprehensive guide for evaluating, securing, and maximizing your EPLI coverage.
—
Phase 1: Pre-Purchase Assessment & Risk Evaluation
Before you shop for a policy, understand your exposure.
– [ ] Conduct an Internal Risk Audit: Review past employee complaints, HR files, termination records, and any previous claims or lawsuits. Identify patterns or potential vulnerabilities.
– [ ] Evaluate Company Size & Growth: Recognize that risk increases with employee count. Rapid growth or high turnover periods often correlate with higher EPLI exposure.
– [ ] Review Current HR Infrastructure:
– [ ] Are employee handbooks and policies (anti-discrimination, anti-harassment, leave, social media) up-to-date and legally compliant?
– [ ] Is there a clear, documented procedure for reporting and investigating complaints?
– [ ] How consistent and documented are your hiring, promotion, discipline, and termination processes?
– [ ] Understand State & Federal Regulations: Laws vary by location. Are you compliant with the FMLA, ADA, Title VII, and relevant state-specific employment laws?
—
Phase 2: Policy Selection & Scrutiny
Not all EPLI policies are created equal. Read the fine print.
– [ ] Coverage Triggers: Does the policy cover claims made *during* the policy period, regardless of when the incident occurred (claims-made), or only incidents that occur during the policy period?
– [ ] Definition of “Claim”: Does it include administrative charges (e.g., from the EEOC or state agencies), as well as formal lawsuits?
– [ ] Key Covered Allegations: Confirm the policy explicitly covers:
– [ ] Wrongful Termination
– [ ] Discrimination (based on sex, race, age, disability, etc.)
– [ ] Sexual Harassment
– [ ] Retaliation
– [ ] Workplace Harassment (non-sexual)
– [ ] Failure to Promote
– [ ] Breach of Employment Contract
– [ ] Negligent Hiring, Supervision, or Retention
– [ ] Invasion of Privacy
– [ ] Defamation
– [ ] Who is Insured?
– [ ] The entity (company, LLC, etc.)
– [ ] Directors, Officers, and Trustees
– [ ] All employees (managers, supervisors, staff)
– [ ] Does it extend to claims by independent contractors or third parties?
– [ ] Defense Costs: Are legal defense costs covered *in addition to* the policy limits (outside limits), or do they erode the total amount available for a settlement (inside limits)? *Outside limits are vastly preferable.*
– [ ] Deductibles & Limits: Are the deductibles per-claim or per-policy period? Are the limits per-claim, per-employee, or aggregate? Do they align with your risk profile and potential exposure?
– [ ] Exclusions: Carefully review what is *not* covered. Common exclusions include:
– [ ] Criminal or fraudulent acts
– [ ] Intentional bodily injury
– [ ] Claims under WARN Act, ERISA, or OSHA
– [ ] Prior & pending litigation (known claims)
– [ ] Contractual liabilities
– [ ] Wage & hour disputes (often a separate endorsement)
– [ ] Duty to Defend vs. Duty to Reimburse: A “duty to defend” policy means the insurer appoints and controls the legal defense—a critical benefit. A “duty to reimburse” policy requires you to manage and pay for defense upfront.
—
Phase 3: Risk Management & Loss Prevention
The best claim is the one that never happens. Insurers reward prevention.
– [ ] Implement Strong HR Practices:
– [ ] Develop and distribute clear, written employment policies.
– [ ] Conduct mandatory, regular training for all employees and managers on harassment prevention, discrimination, and reporting procedures.
– [ ] Maintain meticulous, consistent documentation for all employment actions.
– [ ] Create a Safe Reporting Channel: Ensure multiple, accessible ways for employees to report concerns without fear of retaliation.
– [ ] Conduct Prompt, Impartial Investigations: Have a protocol for investigating all complaints thoroughly and objectively.
– [ ] Secure an Employment Attorney: Establish a relationship with legal counsel specializing in employment law for advice on complex situations *before* they become claims.
– [ ] Utilize Carrier Resources: Many EPLI carriers offer free or discounted HR hotlines, sample policies, and training materials—use them.
—
Phase 4: In the Event of a Claim
Proper response mitigates damage and ensures coverage.
– [ ] Notify Your Insurer IMMEDIATELY: EPLI policies have strict notification requirements. Report any written demand, administrative charge (EEOC, DOL), or lawsuit as soon as you receive it.
– [ ] Preserve All Evidence: Do not alter, delete, or destroy any potentially relevant documents, emails, or records. Implement a legal hold if necessary.
– [ ] Do Not Admit Fault or Discuss Freely: Direct all communications regarding the claim to your designated HR lead and legal counsel.
– [ ] Cooperate Fully with Your Insurer: Provide all requested information promptly and work collaboratively with the assigned defense counsel.
—
Conclusion: An Ongoing Commitment
EPLI is not a substitute for sound employment practices, but a financial backstop when best efforts fall short. Treating your EPLI policy as a dynamic component of your overall business strategy—regularly reviewing coverage, investing in prevention, and responding swiftly to issues—will provide the strongest defense for your assets, your reputation, and your most valuable resource: your people.
Final Annual Review Checklist:
– [ ] Re-assess coverage limits based on company growth.
– [ ] Review policy with your broker and legal counsel.
– [ ] Audit and update HR policies and training programs.
– [ ] Analyze any trends in employee complaints or near-misses.
By following this structured checklist, you transform EPLI from a simple insurance purchase into a cornerstone of a resilient, ethical, and legally defensible workplace.